PDA

View Full Version : First murder trial in 150 years enthralls Australian island


allesennogwat
01-31-2007, 09:16 AM
The descendants of the Bounty mutineers threw the hangman's gibbet into the sea as soon as they arrived on Norfolk Island, and for 150 years there was no murder in the remote South Pacific paradise.

Now New Zealand chef Glenn McNeill, 28, is to go on trial for the horrific killing of 29-year-old Australian woman Janelle Patton in a case which has shocked the tiny island and its 2,000 closely-knit inhabitants.

If convicted, McNeill will not face the death penalty as the notoriously brutal former British penal colony is now a territory of Australia, where capital punishment has been scrapped.

But he faces the prospect of life in jail, and the trial in the old stone courthouse is the focus of intense interest, not least because the taint of suspicion fell on the proud islanders themselves.

After Patton's stabbed and battered body was found at a popular picnic spot on Easter Sunday March 31, 2002, they were subjected to mass fingerprinting, despite protesting that the killer could not be one of them.

A third of the islanders are direct descendants of Fletcher Christian and his band of mutineers who set Captain William Bligh adrift from the British warship the Bounty when they famously fell in love with the South Pacific, and its women, in 1789.

Despite a swirl of rumours over the identity of the murderer there was no progress in the case until McNeill, a father of two, was arrested in February last year in his native New Zealand after what police described as a DNA breakthrough.

Preparations for the long-awaited trial have included fitting the small 175 year-old courthouse with video equipment to broadcast the proceedings to about 100 reporters and members of the public in two large marquees outside.

"There's never been a trial anything like this," said government secretary Peter Maywald. "It's the first murder charge in 150 years. We've had controversial local matters, but nothing like this."

Patton, a hotel restaurant manager who had lived on the island for almost three years, had gone for a walk on the day she died.

Her body, with fractures to her ribs, skull and pelvis as well as stab wounds, was found several hours later, partially wrapped in plastic sheeting, dumped at the local beauty spot.

Patton's parents, Ron and Carol, and her brother Mark are expected to attend the trial in the courthouse, which is overlooked by Rooty Hill road, where Janelle was walking when she disappeared.

Norfolk Island, 1,500 kilometers (900 miles) off the east coast of Australia and 800 kilometres north of New Zealand, is just eight kilometres long by five kilometres wide.

The island was discovered by Captain James Cook in 1774 and soon became one of the most feared and loathed prison colonies in the British Empire until it was abandoned in 1855.

It was settled by the descendants of the Bounty mutineers in 1856, after they found their first refuge on Pitcairn Island too small. Horrified by the reminders of punishments the prisoners had endured, they threw the gibbet into the sea.

The island is now known as a popular holiday destination, and as the home of internationally acclaimed Australian novelist Colleen McCullough, author of The Thorn Birds, Morgan's Run and the Masters of Rome series.

allesennogwat
01-31-2007, 09:17 AM
http://sg.yimg.com/xp/afp/20070131/14/751178147.jpg

First murder trial in 150 years enthralls Australian island

allesennogwat
02-01-2007, 12:44 AM
On a South Pacific island that was once the British empire's most brutal penal colony, where there is now no prison and almost no crime, a New Zealander has pleaded innocent to the first murder charge in 150 years.

Glenn McNeill, 29, a fresh-faced former chef, swallowed nervously as he stood to make his plea in front of his parents and partner in a makeshift courtroom in a centuries old, stone-walled, military barracks.

The father of two denied killing Australian woman Janelle Patton on March 31, 2002 -- Easter Sunday -- and leaving her body with broken bones and stab wounds, half-wrapped in a plastic sheet, at a local beauty spot.

Patton, 29, a restaurant manager, was last seen alive as she walked on a quiet green hill overlooking the 175-year-old courthouse, where two large white tents have been erected to accommodate the media and public.

The discovery of her battered body shocked the 2,000 residents of this dot in the ocean 1,500 kilometers (900 miles) off the east coast of Australia.

Despite its history of inhuman brutality and despair, its green pastures and towering Norfolk Pines, cradled by steep cliffs crashing to a sub-tropical ocean, must qualify it for the overworked description of a South Seas paradise.

Fat Hereford cows graze lush grasses alongside blackened stone remnants of the penal colony where convicts reportedly prayed for execution to escape the cruelty of their lives.

The jailors abandoned the island in 1855 and a year later it was settled by descendants of the mutineers on the British warship the Bounty, who famously fell in love with the South Pacific, and its women, in 1789.

A third of the residents are direct descendants of the mutineers, and the entire island community is so closely-knit that the judge on Thursday closed the court to the media and the public for preliminary legal arguments.

"Given the circumstances on the island, the fact that virtually everybody knows everybody there would be a risk that a potential member of the jury might hear something that they ought not to hear," said judge Mark Weinberg.

The legal arguments are expected to last two days and the jury will be sworn in on Monday.

Weinberg is an Australian Federal Court judge, but also sits as the Chief Justice of Norfolk Island, just eight kilometres long by five kilometres wide with a unique semi-self-governing status.

It is served by flights from Australia just three days a week, and crime is virtually unknown, government secretary Peter Maywald told AFP.

"I've lived here for three and a half years and I haven't taken the keys out of the car's ignition in all that time," said the former Australian civil servant.

"If I fly to Sydney, I leave the car at the airport with the keys in it."

In a strange twist of history there is no jail on this former penal colony, just two police cells, and police deal mainly with traffic offences and minor civil matters, he said.

If McNeill is convicted, he would serve his sentence in Australia or New Zealand.

He faces a maximum penalty of life imprisonment, as capital punishment is outlawed. The Bounty descendants flung the hangman's gibbet into the sea in disgust when they arrived on Norfolk island on June 8, 1856.

If anybody on the island dies -- anybody -- flags are flown at half mast on the day they die and on the day of their funeral.

allesennogwat
02-01-2007, 12:44 AM
http://sg.yimg.com/xp/afp/20070201/12/696723085.jpg


Murder revisits South Pacific island with brutal history